How to Remove Stuck Screws From a Door Hinge - Dengarden - Home and Garden
Updated date:

How to Remove Stuck Screws From a Door Hinge

Eugene has a keen interest in DIY and gardening. Over a 30 year period he has also become self taught in garden power tool maintenance.

how-to-remove-screws-from-a-door-hinge

Stuck Screws and How to Remove Them

You need to remove a door to replace it or lay flooring. You try to undo the screws from the hinges but nope, they won't budge!

Over time, the slots in screw heads get filled with old paint as multiple coats build up. Screws can also rust up in damp environments. The result? Almost impossible to remove screws. Read on to find out how you can sort out the problem.

Most woodscrews now have Phillips heads so they can easily be driven with a cordless drill. Older screws were slotted.

Most woodscrews now have Phillips heads so they can easily be driven with a cordless drill. Older screws were slotted.

Tools Required

  1. Screwdriver
  2. Light hammer

Optional:

  1. Hacksaw
  2. Drill bits
  3. Countersink bit
  4. Centre punch
  5. Dremel rotary tool
  6. Vice grips (locking pliers)
  7. Impact screwdriver
The paint on the heads of these screws needs to be removed.

The paint on the heads of these screws needs to be removed.

Step 1: Clear the Paint From the Top of the Screw

Use the tip of a flat blade screwdriver to clear all the paint off the top of the screw heads, exposing the slots. Tip: If you're right handed, hold the handle of the screwdriver with your right hand hand and the blade with your left hand. Your left hand acts as a restraint, so the screwdriver is less likely to slip, damaging paintwork.

Paint removed from heads, now the slots need to be cleared.

Paint removed from heads, now the slots need to be cleared.

Step 2: Clean the Slots in the Screw Heads

It's often older type wood screws that get seized in timber. Generally these have a slotted head, unlike a Phillips or posidriv head screw.

  • You can use a hammer and flat blade screwdriver as a chisel to clear paint.
  • The blade should ideally be as wide as the slot to clear all the paint. This allows you to use a proper sized screwdriver blade to attempt screw removal.
  • Hammer the screwdriver at a 45 degree angle to push paint sideways out of the slots.
Clear the paint from the slots with a hammer and screwdriver.

Clear the paint from the slots with a hammer and screwdriver.

Clear the slots with a screwdriver.

Clear the slots with a screwdriver.

Step 3: Try Tightening the Screws First

The blade width should be approximately the same diameter as the head of the screw and the blade thickness should be roughly the same width as the slot. If you use a blade that doesn't fit, it's easy to damage the tip of the blade or round the edge of the slot, making removal even more difficult.

Try tightening the screws first. Sometimes this helps to break a screw's grip on the timber.

Step 4: Put Lots of Pressure on the Screwdriver While Unscrewing

The slot in a screw head is rectangular. If you don't use enough pressure behind the screwdriver, pushing into the head, the tip of the blade will likely rise out of the slot and slip, rounding off the edge. This is more likely if the slots were damaged when the screws were removed a couple of times before.

If you're removing the screws from a door hinge, it's a little easier to produce a lot of force on the screwdriver by getting your back against the opposite door jamb. Get down on your hunkers and use your two hands to push as tight as you on the screwdriver, while turning it.

Put your back against the door frame. This enables you to push hard on the screwdriver. Use two hands whilst turning.

Put your back against the door frame. This enables you to push hard on the screwdriver. Use two hands whilst turning.

Step 5: If the Screws Still Won't Undo, Try Hammering the Edges

Often the reason screws are difficult to remove is because they've rusted up, roughening the threads and increasing their hold on the timber. If you still have difficulty removing them, sometimes it helps to hit the edge of the slot, near the perimeter, with a screwdriver or punch and hammer. The impact can release their grip on the timber.

Hammer at right angles to the slot, near the perimeter. This may help to un-stick the screw.

Hammer at right angles to the slot, near the perimeter. This may help to un-stick the screw.

Cut a New Slot in the Head

If the screw has a round head, you can deepen the slot or square it up with a hacksaw. If it's a Phillips screw and the head is damaged, try cutting a new slot with a hacksaw or cutting disk on a Dremel type tool.

Mid Level Dremel Tool

With a Dremel rotary tool you can grind, sand, carve, cut, slot, router, hollow, engrave, polish, sharpen and debur (remove ragged edges from material) lots of materials such as metal, plastic, wood, ceramic and glass. It's suitable for craftwork, DIY, and repair and can be used where a larger power tool such as an angle grinder or power saw would be unsuitable due to its sheer size.

This is a mid level 120 volt corded Dremel (model 3000) with a power rating of 120 watts (1.2 amp motor). It comes in a case with 28 accessories including sanding disks, wire brushes, grinding burrs and cutting wheels. Additional cutting disks are available from Dremel and other sellers on Amazon.

how-to-remove-screws-from-a-door-hinge

Use Vice Grips to Grip the Screw Head

As an alternative to using a screwdriver, you can use a vice grips (locking pliers) to undo screws. The advantage of this tool is that it gives a lot of leverage (also called torque or turning force), much greater than a screwdriver can achieve. To use a vice grips, you first need to undo the screw so that it's a little proud of the timber surface. Use a steel file to make parallel flats on opposite edges of the screw head. This makes it less likely for the grips to turn on the head.

Use an Impact Screwdriver

This tool, available from Amazon is a screwdriver which is fitted with replaceable bits. As you hit the back of the screwdriver with a hammer, the impact pushes the bit hard into the slot so it doesn't climb out on any worn slot edges. The bit is also simultaneously twisted. The twisting force is much greater than what you could produce by hand.

how-to-remove-screws-from-a-door-hinge

If You Can't Remove the Screws, It's Time to Remove the Head

Sometimes it's just plain impossible to remove a screw, so what are the alternatives?

  1. Drill out the head. Use a bit about 1/2 the diameter of the head. If you have a centre punch or even a hard nail, try to make a dent first, which helps to centre the bit. Drill down through the head and eventually you'll reach the shaft of the screw, detaching the head.
  2. Use a countersink bit. Sometimes it's difficult to keep a drill bit centred on a head, especially if it's damaged. You can use a countersink bit as a sort of milling tool to grind away the head. Apply pressure and you may be able to get the point of the bit to penetrate the head, helping to stop it sliding.

How to Remove Phillips Screws

  • Don't try using a worn screwdriver. The four edges on the screwdriver tip should be square. Over time, these edges become rounded, so when twisted, the tip will just slip in a screw head.
  • Newer chipboard type screws may be made from very hard steel, so it can be difficult to cut a slot in the head with a hacksaw. This is where a Dremel tool with a small abrasive cutting disk comes in useful for making new slots.
Posidriv screws, similar to  Phillips head types.

Posidriv screws, similar to Phillips head types.

This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.

© 2019 Eugene Brennan

Comments

rosina matruglio on March 24, 2020:

excellent..very well written

Sourav Rana on January 26, 2020:

Very articulate method of representing information about the subject. One doesn't need to stress the mind in order decipher the subject line in your hub. Just a single review is required to understand everything. I am trying to learn writing this and will seek helpful tips from you Sir.

Finally I can say one thing: Splendid!