Skip to main content

Buying a Lawn Mower: Which Is Best? Electric, Gas, or Battery?

Eugene is an avid gardener and has been passionate about growing things for over 40 years.

Which kind of lawnmower will best suit your needs?

Which kind of lawnmower will best suit your needs?

Which Lawnmower Should I Buy?

This guide provides tips on buying push or walk-behind rotary gasoline (petrol) lawn mowers. It is by no means a comprehensive guide but gives you some ideas about what to look out for when you go to a dealer or home store and are confronted by all the models on display.

Topics covered include lawnmower type, horsepower, width of cut, and deck type.

What About Reel (Cylinder) Mowers?

A reel (also known as a cylinder) mower without an engine is fine for a small area. You can use it to cut a larger area also and it provides great exercise; it's likely to strengthen your arms and back muscles. However, it is by no means easy! Well, at least I don't think so. I haven't used one of these for thirty years and can't recall seeing anyone using one in the recent past. I have one buried in the shed somewhere and I must resurrect it and see how difficult it would be to cut the lawn after all these years!

Reel mowers must be used on relatively short grass. Long and/or wet grass tends to clog them. They cut the grass by shearing it, just like a pair of scissors. The blades rotate and make contact with a bottom blade called the soleplate and these blades must be kept sharp and not rub tightly against this plate, otherwise pushing the machine becomes a chore. Regular lubrication is also necessary.

Engine-Powered Reel Mower

You can of course buy a reel mower powered by an engine. This type of mower is what is used to give the fine finish on golf courses and sports playing fields. They are considerably more expensive than a rotary mower and just like their unpowered counterparts, don't take kindly to very long grass.

Rotary Lawn Mowers

The most common type of small engine lawnmower uses a rotary action for cutting grass. This type of mower consists simply of a metal or plastic deck on which is mounted a vertical crankshaft engine. A metal cutting blade is attached to the end of the shaft. As the blade spins, it cuts the grass which is then thrown into a bag. Some mowers need to be pushed, others have self-drive and you just need to walk behind.

How Much Horsepower Do I Need?

The power of an engine is specified in horsepower, abbreviated to hp. Alternatively, the cc (cubic centimeter) capacity of the engine may be specified (i.e. the volume of the cylinder). There isn't a direct relationship between cc and horsepower as the conversion factor varies from model to model and brand to brand and the efficiency of the engine. However the greater the cc, the greater the horsepower. Power ranges are usually between 2 and 7 hp. 6 horsepower is roughly equivalent to 190 cc.

For a very small lawn of say 1000 square feet or less, a 3.5 horsepower mower should suffice. Power becomes an issue when you tend to let the grass get long, and a mower with 5 or 5.5 hp has the advantage of being able to handle long patches without slowing down or stalling. A more powerful engine will also be more capable of driving the mower forward when the bag is full and the wheels sink down into the soft surface of a lawn with lots of moss.

What Sized Cut?

The width of the cut produced by a rotary lawn mower is determined by the length of the spinning blade. This ranges from 15 to 25 inch but mowers with 18, 20, or 21-inch blades are probably the most common. An 18-inch mower is usually a relatively neat machine which makes it easier when you have to maneuver around trees, flower beds, and other obstacles in lawns, or have to cut into corners.

How Big Should the Bag Be?

As big as possible. If the grass gets long or you have a large area to cut, you don't want to be regularly stopping to empty it. A good-sized bag is 13 gallons equivalent to 2 cubic feet or 60 liters.

Steel, Aluminum, or Plastic Deck?

The deck or body of the mower which the engine sits on can be made from several materials:

Scroll to Continue

Read More From Dengarden

  • Steel Deck: This is usually the cheapest and strongest material from which decks are made. The disadvantage is that it corrodes over time unless the underside of the deck is cleaned regularly and allowed to dry before the mower is put into storage.
  • Aluminum Deck: Not as strong as steel but won't corrode from just getting wet, unlike steel. Corrosion occurs when a mower is left through winter with a coating of grass on the underside of the deck. This ferments and becomes acidic and this is what corrodes the aluminum. Sometimes near the end of the season, you think there will be one more cut, and the mower then gets left in the garage until the grass gets long enough for this last cut to happen, which it never does. The mower then gets forgotten about and this is when corrosion occurs. So it is important to wash away any grass from the underside of the deck and store it in a dry garage or shed over winter.
  • Synthetic Deck: Made from polymers under the brand names Xenoy and Nexite. These are more expensive than aluminum or steel. The advantage is that grass is less likely to stick to the underside and these materials don't corrode. The jury is out though on whether they last. Some people think they are great. Others reckon they aren't durable, crack from the impact of stones and twigs, and can become brittle due to exposure to the Sun.

Underside of lawnmower deck and blade

Underside of lawnmower deck and blade

Engine Brand

Try to get a mower with a well-known engine model. This is important if the engine needs to be repaired or serviced as regards getting spare parts. Briggs and Stratton, Honda, and Tecumseh are well-known engine manufacturers.

Adjusting Height of Cut

Some mowers have a single lever for adjusting the height of the deck and cut. This is very convenient. Others require you to adjust the wheels individually. The advantage of this is that one side of the mower can be raised. I think the single height adjuster is the best.

Weight of The Mower

If you have to move the mower around, weight needs to be taken into account. A smaller mower can be lifted into the trunk of a car with some effort, a larger mower may require two people to lift it. Mowers with steel decks are heavier than those with decks made from aluminium or plastic.

Electric or Pull Start Mowers

Electric start mowers are an option if you find it difficult to pull the starter cord on the mower. Some mowers are electric start only and don't have a recoil starter (pull start). So if the battery is flat, the alternator fails or the starter motor doesn't work, you can't start the mower. So my advice is to avoid these.

Obviously, the extra parts add to the cost of the mower and more working parts mean there's more to go wrong. You may also have to buy a new battery every so often.

Mulching Mowers

These mince up the grass and distribute it on the lawn so that you don't need to collect it in a bag.When the clippings decay, they return nutrients to the ground.

Mulching mowers are more expensive than non-mulching types and use more gas. Engines are usually higher powered and 5hp is at the bottom of the range.

Corded Electric and Cordless Rechargeable Battery Lawnmowers

So what are the alternatives to gasoline? Well, you could go for an electric mower.


  • Lower noise
  • Cost of electricity used is a fraction of that of gas
  • No regular maintenance costs unlike a gas mower which requires replacement of oil, spark plug, and air filter at regular intervals
  • No exhaust fumes
  • They always start the first time and don't need to be pull started
  • Mowers are much lighter so easier to maneuver and lift into a car


  • The power cord can be a nuisance and care needs to be taken to avoid running over it
  • Potential danger of electric shock if used in wet conditions
  • Power is generally limited to about 1500 watts or 2 horsepower. Even a low-powered gas mower would be rated at about 3.5HP. Because of this, they are limited to regular cutting of grass (Cutting 6-inch long grass is not an option!)

Battery Mowers

Another option is a battery mower. These use a rechargeable 24 or 36-volt power pack. They offer all the advantages of an electric mower with the additional benefit of freedom from a power cord. However, they can be quite heavy and are more suited to use on level ground without slopes because of the effort of trying to push the machine uphill. Cordless battery mowers are fine, but generally they're less powerful than those with engines and can't be used for cutting very long/damp grass or grass with lots of moss in one go, without doing multiple cuts to shorten it. This should be taken into consideration if rain or your work means that getting out to cut the grass has to be postponed and the grass grows really long.

High Lift Blades Provide Better Lift for Sucking Up Grass

Rotary mowers are often fitted with a general-purpose blade that can either cut or mulch. A high lift blade however has greater curvature at the tips or attached fins to increase lift. While it isn't so good at mulching grass, a high lift blade does what the name suggests. It creates a more powerful airflow for sucking up grass from a lawn and blowing it into the bag. This helps if the grass is a bit moist or lush in which case a standard blade will struggle and grass can clog the exit chute. A mower may be supplied and fitted with a high lift blade or it could be an optional replacement for the general-purpose one. However, a high lift blade mightn't actually be available.

This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.

© 2012 Eugene Brennan


Eugene Brennan (author) from Ireland on July 27, 2017:

Hi Dave,

As regards a reel (cylinder) mower giving a better cut, it probably depends on how well the blades are sharpened and whether the blade makes good contact with the sole plate along all it's length so that it shears the grass properly. I remember trying to adjust a non-powered version of one of these in the days before I had a motor mower, and it was difficult to get it perfect. Usually they have rollers to give a lawn nice stripes, but rotary mowers are also available with a roller.

Thanks for the comment!

DAVE on July 27, 2017:

As a kid, I used to mow lawns to earn money. So I've used and repaired many of them. As to a powered reel mower it is supposed to give you a better cut-I never found that to be the case. Also it is far slower than a rotary mower and it cannot cut close to beds, trees, buildings etc. The good news is it is far easier on the engine so they last far longer. Getting one sharpened is far more expensive then a rotary mower and finding a shop that has the proper equipment and someone who knows how to do it will be hard.

RE: starting engines

Today, they all have electronic ignition so a far hotter spark when starting. It is far easier.

Eugene Brennan (author) from Ireland on June 03, 2012:

Glad to be of help! I'm going to pull my reel mower out of the shed at some stage and get it back working. I haven't used it for about thirty years. It might be just a pile of rust at this stage though!

wetnosedogs from Alabama on June 03, 2012:


thanks for the mention of my article on the reel mowers!

It is ideal for me since I have too much trouble starting gas mowers. The reel mowers of today are lightweight and easier to push than the older rotary.

Related Articles